When did the idea of non evil werewolves come from?

The place to talk about where a lot of things started. Stories and history, references, etc.
Dreamer
Legendary
Legendary
Posts: 879
Joined: Tue Mar 06, 2007 12:49 pm
Location: Tucson AZ

When did the idea of non evil werewolves come from?

Post by Dreamer »

I mean, there is no precedent for the non-evil, non-cursed werewolf in mythology. The good ones are usually under some curse, so where did the idea of the non-cursed, non-evil werewolf come from?
XIV
User avatar
Xiroteus
Legendary
Legendary
Posts: 1052
Joined: Sat Jul 01, 2006 10:24 pm
Gender: Male
Mood: Happy
Location: United States
Contact:

Post by Xiroteus »

I do not have the answer to where the idea came from.

I had thought about non-evil, self -aware, in control of their own mind werewolves for a few years then found out quite a few other people liked the same once I had the internet.
User avatar
*nagowteena*
Legendary
Legendary
Posts: 2900
Joined: Thu Dec 07, 2006 7:23 am
Custom Title: TV!!!!!!!!!!!!
Gender: Female
Mood: RAR!
Location: "Hell"Paso, Texas U.S.A. Rewatching SMALLVILLE.
Contact:

Post by *nagowteena* »

Xiroteus wrote:I do not have the answer to where the idea came from.

I had thought about non-evil, self -aware, in control of their own mind werewolves for a few years then found out quite a few other people liked the same once I had the internet.

same here.


and plus, I have a feeling the non-evil werewolves have been around longer then your giving them credit for.

it's just a lot of people who watch movies like werewolves to be evil.


and plus with the legends a lot of people way back when thought a lot of things were evil. so I guess it went on from there.
Image Image
Yeah, that hits the spot..DeviantArt ~ Youtube Avatar by Z
Dreamer
Legendary
Legendary
Posts: 879
Joined: Tue Mar 06, 2007 12:49 pm
Location: Tucson AZ

Post by Dreamer »

Xiroteus wrote:I do not have the answer to where the idea came from.

I had thought about non-evil, self -aware, in control of their own mind werewolves for a few years then found out quite a few other people liked the same once I had the internet.
NO lidding! I had the same idea!
XIV
User avatar
Kelpten
Legendary
Legendary
Posts: 308
Joined: Sun Aug 21, 2005 7:23 pm

Post by Kelpten »

Well, the native americans had non-evil shapeshifters, so that idea is very old. In Europe, however, since wolves were seen as mindless predators who ate the livestock, they were always evil. Although the Native Americans were here first, the current America has been influenced more heavily by Europe, so that's where our culture got the evil werewolf. The concept of a good werewolf just recently resurfaced, I think from novels and the internet. There's my two bits.
Dreamer
Legendary
Legendary
Posts: 879
Joined: Tue Mar 06, 2007 12:49 pm
Location: Tucson AZ

Post by Dreamer »

Yeah, but who do you think did it first?
XIV
theMoonlite
Legendary
Legendary
Posts: 112
Joined: Sun Jun 11, 2006 8:50 pm

Post by theMoonlite »

*nagowteena* wrote: and plus with the legends a lot of people way back when thought a lot of things were evil. so I guess it went on from there.
I agree with that. I suppose it's all just passed around from person to person, their thoughts and ideas. People fear the unknown, so when ever they come across something like that frightens them, they're obviously going to tell all the scary parts they encountered; and keep a closeminded view of what happened. I hightly doubt that there would be truely evil Werewolves, but you really never know. I just think hoomans in general are quick to judge others without getting to know them.
cumulusprotagonist
Legendary
Legendary
Posts: 1228
Joined: Tue Apr 24, 2007 4:53 pm
Custom Title: Possessed by the Ghost of Cumulus
Location: Another Place
Contact:

Post by cumulusprotagonist »

It is pretty basic really.
If evil exists then so can good.
Maybe I am wrong...

DO NOT CLICK ON THIS LINK!!!!!!


Avatar Cited Sources:
Photography by ___________
Photo Manipulation by Z
User avatar
*nagowteena*
Legendary
Legendary
Posts: 2900
Joined: Thu Dec 07, 2006 7:23 am
Custom Title: TV!!!!!!!!!!!!
Gender: Female
Mood: RAR!
Location: "Hell"Paso, Texas U.S.A. Rewatching SMALLVILLE.
Contact:

Post by *nagowteena* »

cumulusprotagonist wrote:It is pretty basic really.
If evil exists then so can good.
BINGO!!! :D


and now it all depends who is on what side.

if there is good, there is evil.

if there is evil, there is good. :howl:  :oo
Image Image
Yeah, that hits the spot..DeviantArt ~ Youtube Avatar by Z
theMoonlite
Legendary
Legendary
Posts: 112
Joined: Sun Jun 11, 2006 8:50 pm

Post by theMoonlite »

cumulusprotagonist wrote:It is pretty basic really.
If evil exists then so can good.
Yes, there is good, and there is evil, but there are also grey areas (I believe so, at least).
Ashkin-Tyr
Legendary
Legendary
Posts: 197
Joined: Mon Jul 24, 2006 4:30 am
Custom Title: On the scotch tape of reality, third door to the left.
Location: Minneapolis, MN
Contact:

Post by Ashkin-Tyr »

Kelpten wrote:In Europe, however, since wolves were seen as mindless predators who ate the livestock, they were always evil.
In European mythology werewolves were not always evil. They had accounts predating the 1600's of werewolves who were good-natured.

Examples:

A werewolf who saved a band of travelers

A werewolf Bishop

Thiess and his comrades, who battled witches for the safety of their village.
Dreamer
Legendary
Legendary
Posts: 879
Joined: Tue Mar 06, 2007 12:49 pm
Location: Tucson AZ

Post by Dreamer »

Ashkin-Tyr wrote:
Kelpten wrote:In Europe, however, since wolves were seen as mindless predators who ate the livestock, they were always evil.
In European mythology werewolves were not always evil. They had accounts predating the 1600's of werewolves who were good-natured.

Examples:

A werewolf who saved a band of travelers

A werewolf Bishop

Thiess and his comrades, who battled witches for the safety of their village.
YEah, but I think those first two were curses, and the third one was more of an astral-projection in animal form type thing.
XIV
cumulusprotagonist
Legendary
Legendary
Posts: 1228
Joined: Tue Apr 24, 2007 4:53 pm
Custom Title: Possessed by the Ghost of Cumulus
Location: Another Place
Contact:

Post by cumulusprotagonist »

theMoonlite wrote:
cumulusprotagonist wrote:It is pretty basic really.
If evil exists then so can good.
Yes, there is good, and there is evil, but there are also grey areas (I believe so, at least).
If evil exists then so can good. If evil and good both exist then so can everything in between. If this creates a line going from good to evil then the grey areas could exist outside of the line. Maybe there are two good and evil lines. One line is for external good and evil and the other is for internal good and evil. The gray areas are not involved in how it is basic to think of the possibility of a good and moral werewolf.

But since you went and started it.

Let us say the right of a line is heading towards good and the left is heading towards evil. Let us say this is external. The internal line has good heading up and evil heading south. Now we have a graph. The Cursed werewolf type could be in the second quadrant. That is they could be good internally but evil externally. A werewolf just like any other person could be anywhere on the graph depending upon the individual. They could even be outside of the graph off in inconceivable territory. Inconceivable territory to some people can exist on the graph, but inconceivable territory to most people is what lies outside of it.

If someone is externally evil that does not mean they are truly evil it means they are perceived to be evil by society. Only if the individual is internally evil are they truly evil. I am unsure how many people will understand this but there really is no way for someone to know who is and is not truly evil, regardless of what they have done. You never know everything that leads up to an externally evil act or everything surrounding it.
Maybe I am wrong...

DO NOT CLICK ON THIS LINK!!!!!!


Avatar Cited Sources:
Photography by ___________
Photo Manipulation by Z
Ashkin-Tyr
Legendary
Legendary
Posts: 197
Joined: Mon Jul 24, 2006 4:30 am
Custom Title: On the scotch tape of reality, third door to the left.
Location: Minneapolis, MN
Contact:

Post by Ashkin-Tyr »

Dreamer wrote:YEah, but I think those first two were curses, and the third one was more of an astral-projection in animal form type thing.
Well, I was responding to a previous post about Europe's werewolves, not necessarily if they were cursed or not. I apologize for deviating from your topic.

In the account of Thiess, there was no mention of astral projection, but a physical transformation. If you are curious to read up on Thiess, I made a thread about it several months ago, so its around midway through this forum.
User avatar
Scott Gardener
Legendary
Legendary
Posts: 4731
Joined: Wed Dec 15, 2004 11:36 pm
Gender: Male
Mood: Excited
Location: Rockwall, Texas (and beyond infinity)
Contact:

Max Headroom, New Coke, Reaganomics, and good guy werewolves

Post by Scott Gardener »

Actually, non-evil werewolves probably came first. In the old days of hunter-gatherer humanity, shapeshifting rites were likely performed before hunts, and wolves were likely an animal of choice. Hunters would don skins and envision becoming wolves to be better hunters. And, they fed the tribe. Lycanthropy may have been a mainstream profession some 20,000 years ago.

European thinking and its obsession with "good and evil" popularized evil werewolves, though pre-Medieval legends such as King Lycaon show that it didn't start in the Middle Ages. The idea of reinventing werewolves today as something other than monsters, however, probably dates to the eighties.
Taking a Gestalt approach, since it's the "in" thing...
Dreamer
Legendary
Legendary
Posts: 879
Joined: Tue Mar 06, 2007 12:49 pm
Location: Tucson AZ

Post by Dreamer »

Great info Scott! But what do you think was the first story back then that thought of werewolves like that?
XIV
Lavadragon
Dealing with the Change
Dealing with the Change
Posts: 16
Joined: Mon Aug 27, 2007 8:43 am
Location: My Mind

Post by Lavadragon »

*nagowteena* wrote: and plus, I have a feeling the non-evil werewolves have been around longer then your giving them credit for.
Chances are this is true, in many cultures and folklore etc mythical animals such as dragons, werewolves and such creatures were "good" or symbolic of good things however now most people believe that such creature were and still are "evil" this is mainly down to Christianity (no offense). When the church discovered that people idolised beings other than god the demonised these poor creatures and associated them with the devil in order to discourage people and this has lead to the mainstream belief that werewolves and other creatures are evil.
If you can imagine a vast room, walls covered by shelf after shelf of books and ancient artifacts, with a lone person sitting quietly on a chair reading by candle light. Yup thats me
User avatar
Absolute Wolf
Legendary
Legendary
Posts: 102
Joined: Sun Sep 02, 2007 8:48 am
Location: You don't want to know...
Contact:

Post by Absolute Wolf »

I'll try not to repeat what others said about good and evil...They are true. Yet I'm sure that most of the people feared all things that they couldn't control in that time, or had no reasonable explanation for it.They probably didn't care much if a werewolf was good or evil...It could have saved 100 lives. It was still considered something related to evil no matter what.( I guess, I can say that in that time the people were influenced ). If wolves were considered the servants of the evil, then I don't want to know what were werewolves considered.
Anyway...Even today! It's not really accepted,that just as there are evil werewolves , there are good ones. The two ( good&evil) cannot be separated really.Only balanced!
At least now we can see some changes that people try not to think of it as something negative. :D
User avatar
RedEye
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 3400
Joined: Sun Jun 25, 2006 11:45 pm
Custom Title: Master of Meh
Gender: Male
Mood: Meh...
Location: Somewhere between here and Wolf Bend, Montana.

Post by RedEye »

The first story that took that line? Good Were's as well as Evil Were's?
Dunno. There are references in the Tain Bo Cualainge (Tahn-Boe-Coolnyeah) of a tribe or Clann of Irish Werewolves that fought beside Chucullan (the hero of the story) and that dates to the third or fourth century CE.
Regrettably, all the males (Warriors) were killed...

That's the earliest reference of Werewolf Hero-types I know of.
RedEye: The Wulf and writer who might really be a Kitsune...
User avatar
WordWolf
Legendary
Legendary
Posts: 53
Joined: Sat Dec 25, 2004 9:10 am
Custom Title: ad bestiae Christi
Location: New York City.

Post by WordWolf »

Fine-I'm late to this discussion. Here's what I say...


In the Western Hemisphere, people changing into animals was often
acceptable and fine, not necessarily evil, nor good (depends on the person.)


In the Eastern Hemisphere, where the animal was respected, the idea of
changing into one would be admirable. So, there were people who were fine
with wanting to become the wolf or the bear (Vikings and so on).

As for cultures like the Ainu in Asia, the aborigines in Australia, they lack
web access, so I can GUESS what they agree with. If I were to GUESS, I'd say
the same is true for them-of animals that are predators in their areas.
(In South America, there were no wereWOLVES, for example, since there
were no WOLVES.)

Jacob Thiess in Livonia was a considerable exception, since he lived a LOT
later into "modern civilization" than the other examples,
and because he was a devout, fanatical Christian.
When he was told to recant, and agree with the usual rap of
"I made a deal with Satan", he testified to being a more devout Christian
than his accusers.
I've seen the following attributed to him:
"I'm as Christian as any of you!"

I do know he refused services from a priest, since he considered himself
more devout than any priest. Since he said he and his were
"the dogs of God" and fought for the harvest, one can see why he concluded
that. (Whether or not it was true, it was consistent.)
Doruk Golcu
Legendary
Legendary
Posts: 625
Joined: Mon Jun 06, 2005 2:38 pm

Post by Doruk Golcu »

From Sabine Baring-Gould's 'The Book of Were-wolves':

Olaus relates also in c. xlvii. the story of a certain nobleman who was travelling through a large forest with some peasants in his retinue who dabbled in the black art. They found no house where they could lodge for the night, and were well-nigh famished. Then one of the peasants offered, if all the rest would hold their tongues as to what he should do, that he would bring them a lamb from a distant flock.

He thereupon retired into the depths of the forest and changed his form into that of a wolf, fell upon the flock, and brought a lamb to his companions in his mouth. They received it with gratitude. Then he retired once more into the thicket, and transformed himself back again into his human shape.

[1. OLAUS MAGNUS: Historia de Vent. Septent. Basil. 15, lib. xviii. cap. 45.]
Dreamer
Legendary
Legendary
Posts: 879
Joined: Tue Mar 06, 2007 12:49 pm
Location: Tucson AZ

Post by Dreamer »

Ashkin-Tyr wrote:
Kelpten wrote:In Europe, however, since wolves were seen as mindless predators who ate the livestock, they were always evil.
In European mythology werewolves were not always evil. They had accounts predating the 1600's of werewolves who were good-natured.

Examples:

A werewolf who saved a band of travelers

A werewolf Bishop
Can you give me the links to those two stories, seeing as I can't find them on the internet?

Also, just as a quick note, my werewolves were more like the wolfman in design (Actually more like catboys with more fur and claws) before I discovered that others had similar ideas to me (Alpha Luna was my first skirmish with the idea)
XIV
Ashkin-Tyr
Legendary
Legendary
Posts: 197
Joined: Mon Jul 24, 2006 4:30 am
Custom Title: On the scotch tape of reality, third door to the left.
Location: Minneapolis, MN
Contact:

Post by Ashkin-Tyr »

Dreamer wrote:Can you give me the links to those two stories, seeing as I can't find them on the internet?
I found those two particular stories/accounts in a couple of non-fiction books at my school library. One book, I believe, was called "Werewolves" by Daniel Cohen. The other was "Werewolves and Other Mythological Creatures" (or titled something very similar). I discovered them while I was writing a research paper for my English class a couple years back when I was in high school.

If you go to a public or school library and find some books on werewolves, I'm sure you'd be able to find the accounts.
User avatar
pandawolf
Pack Member
Pack Member
Posts: 24
Joined: Wed Oct 24, 2007 7:23 am

Post by pandawolf »

Well maybe the first werewolves were cursed and evil. But some time later they leanered to beat the curse or suppress it
User avatar
GvnDarklighter
Dealing with the Change
Dealing with the Change
Posts: 10
Joined: Fri Dec 22, 2006 11:21 pm
Location: Virginia

Post by GvnDarklighter »

I can't remember where I found it right off-hand, but I recently read a reference to a unique Medieval werewolf trial wherein the accused party claimed that she was indeed a physical werewolf and that werewolves were actually warriors of God who helped the angels battle the forces of Satan. Interesting, because I think that's the only Christian-based good werewolf I've ever heard of. I'll see if I can remember where I found that later.

Also, Redwolf, what is this Irish epic you've mentioned a few times, the one about Chucullan? And where did you find it? I can't find it anywhere and I'm always looking for new Old English, Germanic, or Celtic texts.
Post Reply