Page 1 of 2

Does this make anyone else nervous?

Posted: Thu Sep 21, 2006 2:37 pm
by Short Tail
For the first time in many decades we have built a machine that exceeds our powers of prediction.
That is what a scientist said about the experiment they are planning on as well as this:
They estimate the possibility of accidentally destroying the planet as extremely low.
http://www.nzherald.co.nz/topic/story.c ... d=10400645
:shudder:

Posted: Thu Sep 21, 2006 2:41 pm
by Moon_Lover
Children with nitro, my friends, children with nitro.

Posted: Thu Sep 21, 2006 2:45 pm
by Figarou
They turn it on, opens a portal, then some strange creature emerges and destroys us all.


After that, they'll make a movie from it.


oh wait...its been done already. :P

Posted: Thu Sep 21, 2006 2:52 pm
by White Paw
well .... here comes the end of the world..... :roll:

Posted: Thu Sep 21, 2006 2:54 pm
by Set
No, I'm not worried.

A black hole won't suck in everything in the universe. You have to be within a certain distance of it for it to pull. If you're not in the field of gravity you're fine. Even if there are mini black holes created by this thing, the field will be so small as to not even tug on your hair if you're within three feet of the thing.

Think of space as a flat plane, and a black hole as a dent in that plane. You won't fall into the hole unless you're close enough to slide down the edge of the dent.

Posted: Thu Sep 21, 2006 4:00 pm
by MoonKit
Set wrote:No, I'm not worried.

A black hole won't suck in everything in the universe. You have to be within a certain distance of it for it to pull. If you're not in the field of gravity you're fine. Even if there are mini black holes created by this thing, the field will be so small as to not even tug on your hair if you're within three feet of the thing.

Think of space as a flat plane, and a black hole as a dent in that plane. You won't fall into the hole unless you're close enough to slide down the edge of the dent.
Thats true but black holes suck items in over long distances. Though if there are mini ones, Im not worried about being sucked up..maybe if I work near that thing...

I hate when humans try to play god...just shut up and enjoy it for what it is instead of trying to control it. :x

Posted: Thu Sep 21, 2006 4:10 pm
by Fang
This is the same thing that happened in the garden, God said don't touch the fruit of the tree of knowlege, and man not only touched it, but ate it and ended off worse :x

Posted: Thu Sep 21, 2006 4:23 pm
by Moon_Lover
I think that the biggest problem is the fact that the only real attribute that humans have is their mind (When they use it). Due to this thye are striving ever harder to prove that they are superior to the other species of the world, if not the universe.
That, and, as said before, they have no respect for natural process. If you can get man to respect nature, it'll not only be a leap in the right direction, it would be a catapult.

Everyone blames the serpent...

Posted: Thu Sep 21, 2006 4:52 pm
by Set
Fang wrote:This is the same thing that happened in the garden, God said don't touch the fruit of the tree of knowlege, and man not only touched it, but ate it and ended off worse :x
I've already ranted about that particular subject once, and I'm not going to bother with it again. I'm merely going to point out that's a VERY BAD analogy to use. If you ask me, man ended up better off, for man was no longer merely an ignorant slave that he was before eating from the tree.

It does annoy me to some extent that every scientific experiment or achievement is considered "playing god". If you really think that way, I'll be sure to shove you in a time machine and send you back to the dark ages where you belong.

Posted: Thu Sep 21, 2006 4:57 pm
by Teh_DarkJokerWolf
StarGate anyone? :P

That could be a total disater..Eh I think man has done enough damage to the poor earth..


A black hole?! Ick..After seeing that one Eps on StarGate SG1 I believe it's Season 2, disc 4, episode 15, "A Matter of Time" about that Black hole..I am not liking this at all :(


Check it out and see what I mean :P

Re: Everyone blames the serpent...

Posted: Thu Sep 21, 2006 5:03 pm
by lupine
[quote="Set"][quote="Fang"]This is the same thing that happened in the garden, God said don't touch the fruit of the tree of knowlege, and man not only touched it, but ate it and ended off worse If you ask me, man ended up better off, for man was no longer merely an ignorant slave that he was before eating from the tree


This IS of course assuming your a christian and believe in the bible. That being the case yeah, you may harbour either one of those views. BUT.... If like me, you feel that the Bible was one of the best selling pieces of science fiction ever written, you would prefer to just shout very loudly at the scientists...'DON'T MEDDLE WITH THINGS YOU DON'T UNDERSTAND!!!!'. Yes, things like this make me nervous. :)

Posted: Thu Sep 21, 2006 6:04 pm
by Fang
Set, I was raised christian, i have since switched, I was using it as an example of how man can destroy everything he holds dear hith one simple decision, as for this experiment, a 10 to the negative 40 chance of earth being destroyed still is not good enough for me, If it's dangerous, don't Fu*k with it!

Posted: Thu Sep 21, 2006 7:00 pm
by Shadow Wulf
Oh my god!! This is just like that book Angels and Demons!! Has anyone read that book? It talks about this in it!! The antimatter, CERN, In Switserland. OMG!! This is awsome!!! :o :cafinated:

Posted: Thu Sep 21, 2006 7:02 pm
by lupine
About a quarter of the way into it now. Doesn't seem to be grabbing me tho.

Posted: Thu Sep 21, 2006 7:08 pm
by Shadow Wulf
What!?!! That book is the best book I haver ever read so far, Im not finish and I am in the quater into like you are. Im not much of a reader but this book has me facinated.

Posted: Thu Sep 21, 2006 7:15 pm
by lupine
Not knocking the book, Just have lots going on so I can't get into it. Loved the DaVinci Code and heard this was even better.

Posted: Thu Sep 21, 2006 7:26 pm
by Figarou

Posted: Thu Sep 21, 2006 7:35 pm
by Short Tail
Set wrote:No, I'm not worried.

A black hole won't suck in everything in the universe. You have to be within a certain distance of it for it to pull. If you're not in the field of gravity you're fine. Even if there are mini black holes created by this thing, the field will be so small as to not even tug on your hair if you're within three feet of the thing.

Think of space as a flat plane, and a black hole as a dent in that plane. You won't fall into the hole unless you're close enough to slide down the edge of the dent.
Set, a black hole created out of this machine would not swallow up the whole universe, that is physically impossible, yet a black hole can pull things twards it from farther distances away. Take for example the black hole that is at the center of our, and hypothesized to be one at the middle of all the galxies. How else would one stay together and continue spiraling without some supermassive gravitational force pulling everything twards it? Back to this story though, A small black hole could very easily destroy the whole planet. Since one of this size might be stable enough to not dissipate, (many microscopic black holes have been made in labs, but these evaporate due to the amount of mass not being enough to sustain it) it would be pulled twards the earth collecting all the matter that passes throught its event horizon as it fell through, and continue falling through the plannet then being pulled back until it had enough matter to hold it in place at the center of the Earth where it would slowly pull the planet into it self.
Also when dealing with black holes, you cannot think of space as a 1 dimentional plane because the beauty of black holes is that they affect all 4 (known) planes of space, Hight, Width, Length, and Space time.

Posted: Thu Sep 21, 2006 7:44 pm
by Short Tail
What the heck? He cant even get Hawking right.
For one thing, theoretical physicist Stephen Hawking calculated all black holes should emit radiation, and that tiny black holes should lose more mass than they absorb, evaporating within a billionth of a trillionth of a trillionth of a second,

Hawking did indeed calculate that black holes emit radiation, but he never said anything about man made black holes. I remeber that chapter in the book and it never mentioned tiny black holes. I dont feel good about scientist basing their research off quotes that they doctored themselves...

Posted: Thu Sep 21, 2006 8:00 pm
by Lukas
im neutral here, its not a good idea, but on the other hand the people worrying about the end of the world are thinking what if already, which is a deadly way of thinking and pretty much ruins the point of science
so like i said, neutral :|

Posted: Thu Sep 21, 2006 8:17 pm
by Lupin
Short Tail wrote: Set, a black hole created out of this machine would not swallow up the whole universe, that is physically impossible, yet a black hole can pull things twards it from farther distances away.
It can't pull anything any further than a similarly massed object that isn't a black hole could. That's not how gravity works. If the Sun turned into a black hole right now, the only thing we'd notice 8 minutes later (c ftw) is that it got very dark. Mass is mass, and the volume that this mass is in has no effect on the amount of gravitational attaraction.

Short Tail wrote:
What the heck? He cant even get Hawking right.
For one thing, theoretical physicist Stephen Hawking calculated all black holes should emit radiation, and that tiny black holes should lose more mass than they absorb, evaporating within a billionth of a trillionth of a trillionth of a second,

Hawking did indeed calculate that black holes emit radiation, but he never said anything about man made black holes. I remeber that chapter in the book and it never mentioned tiny black holes. I dont feel good about scientist basing their research off quotes that they doctored themselves...
He doesn't have to specifically say anything about man-made black holes. If they obey the same laws as normal ones do, (and there's nothing to say that they wouldn't) then they will emit Hawking radiation at a rate consistant with the his equations. There's nothing doctored about that.

Anyway, there are way more energetic collisions from gamma rays in the upper atmosphere than anything we can do on the surface. I doubt anything will happen.

Posted: Thu Sep 21, 2006 9:15 pm
by Terastas
Umm. . . I'm a little worried, yes, but I think it's more likely they'll blow up the machine before it creates a force big enough to blow up the planet. I'm definitely going to keep an eye on this one though.

Posted: Thu Sep 21, 2006 9:33 pm
by Lupin
This thread reminds me, someone needs to download all of these, order them, and then make an animated GIF:
http://atlaseye.web.cern.ch/atlaseye/Pi ... 15_geneva/

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ATLAS_experiment

Posted: Thu Sep 21, 2006 9:41 pm
by Figarou
Lupin wrote:This thread reminds me, someone needs to download all of these, order them, and then make an animated GIF:
http://atlaseye.web.cern.ch/atlaseye/Pi ... 15_geneva/

*looks at number of pictures*

GASP!!! Thats a lot of pictures!! I can do it, but it'll take time. Lots of time.

Err....ummmmm....to much time.


Naaa...I have another project I need to finish 1st.

Posted: Thu Sep 21, 2006 9:45 pm
by Lupin
Figarou wrote: GASP!!! Thats a lot of pictures!! I can do it, but it'll take time. Lots of time.

Err....ummmmm....to much time.


Naaa...I have another project I need to finish 1st.
Yeah, that's really the task of automated software.
It would make a kickass movie though.